$29 dollars is a good deal!
But it’s no iPhone killer. What I’ve been saying ever since I’ve been a Mac user has been this: “It’s all about the experience.” And with that, my $29 myTouch 4G, running Android falls short. The overall experience on the iPhone is easier and more intuitive and just feels better. I think it comes down to two things:
- UI
- Closed System
The User Interface from Apple is fantastic. It feels simple by design. The first experience one might have with the phone is it’s looks. If we take away the physical look of the phones (I think the iPhone 4 is absolutely stunning) and pair it down just to the screen and operating system the iPhone’s iOS stands out. The thought that goes into itsy bitsy details are there. Typography is ever present. Letters aren’t uncomfortably close to edges of boxes. Round corners or square corners fit within their space – not competing for visual attention. The list goes on and on. Your Android phone, or my Android phone running T-Mobile and HTC’s skinned Sense UI from the factory try to alleviate or address the GUI in a positive way – but in the end there is not that attention to detail or that coherent feeling across applications that is inherently part of iOS. I installed Cyanogen Mod 7 with the latest version of Android 2.3.3 a.k.a. Gingerbread. It removes the Sense UI and cleans things up a bit. It’s a step in the right direction but still not on par, let alone kill.
As far as using the OS – there are many things that are predictable about iOS. The lack of hardware buttons creates a common theme of swipe left and right to navigate. It could be that I’m used to this method of navigation but it’s common in almost all applications. In Android you have at least 5 hardware buttons to access the OS. The ‘menu’ button is nice because it brings up settings, then there is a ‘back’ button, a ‘home’ button and on my phone the ‘genius’ button (on other phones the ‘search’ button) and at last the track button thingy. It takes a while to get used to and can be confusing as to what button does what? The beauty of iOS is that all of the navigation, sans ‘home’ button, is virtual – so there will be visual clues as to what that button does. It eliminates guessing. What I’m really getting at is that the overall experiences takes less time to get familiar with and makes it easy to use for simple tasks. On the other hand the Android OS’s menu button seems to have special magic and does allow quick access to an applications settings. This I do like.
In the end. My new phone is really nice. Visually its not as clean as the iPhone line. But for a geek its open source platform is awesome because I can modify the heck out of it without much work. It’s fast and has a great built in navigation app that trumps my TomTom. So I’m a very satisfied customer. And in two years when my contract is up. The Android OS might have grown up enough to keep me here.
So… recently this summer I tore my PCL (grade 2) and my meniscus while climbing in the gym preparing for my summer climbing trip to the Frankenjura (awesome area in Germany). Bummer, I know. I still went to Germany – climbed a tad, came back, and had surgery on the meniscus one week after my return to The States. Afterward, I underwent physical therapy (PT) for the meniscus and PCL.